The economist Andy Xie wrote an insightful article in this month’s Caijing Magazine comparing how Japan’s failure to restructure its economy in the early 1990′s has a counterpart in China’s fiscal stimulus program.

Thus, China’s corporate sector is now behaving in a way similar to what was seen in Japan two decades ago. China’s businesses increasingly focus on asset investment rather than core business. When an asset bubble boosts corporate profits, it seems benign at first. Nobody sees the harm. However, when businesses earn profits from the investments in each other rather than their corporate businesses, their operating profitability deteriorates because they don’t invest in their core businesses anymore. Accounting profitability is just a bubble.

Show me the money!

As I traveled across China recently, it was rare to hear about a business whose officials are enthusiastic about their core business. But everyone seems excited about financial activities. The lending boom in the first half of 2009 seems to have been channeled mostly into asset markets by the corporate sector.

Landed gentry:

In particular, property seems to have become a main profit source for most big businesses. China’s corporate borrowing one way or another goes into the land market. And property development has become the most important source of profit for China’s corporate sector. If a manufacturing business is buoyant, odds are it is profiting from property development. The banking sector reports high profitability due to direct or indirect loans for property development. Property development profit is actually from land appreciation. If property development profitability is measured according to land price at sale time, the development itself would not be profitable.||

Keireitsu with Chinese characteristics?

China’s corporate sector increasingly looks like a shadow banking system. It raises funds from banks, through commercial bills or the corporate bond market, and then channels the funds into the land market. The resulting land inflation underwrites corporate profitability and improves their creditworthiness in the short term.

Enriching, but hardly productive.